Rock Dwellers Attacking Catfish

JerryJ

CCA Members
My problem is I can’t seem to keep rock-dwelling Tanganyikans with Synodontis catfish. I have a 75 gallon tank with fifteen Cyprichromis, a compressiceps, and five S. lucipinnis catfish. These fish get along well. But I have had to rehome a Julidochromis transcriptus, a J. marksmithii, and a caudopunctatus (all single fish) because they all harassed the catfish. Have others seen this problem? I could try a leleupi or something in the N. brichardi family, but my understanding is they are even more aggressive than the rock dwellers I had to get rid of. Has anyone had success with such a combination? Do you think I’ve just been unlucky? I could keep trying, but I’d like to know something about the probability of success!
 

Charlutz

Members
I kept schools of petricola in my tanks with no issues even with breeding julies, leleupi and brichardi (not all in the same tank). You might’ve just gotten some aggressive individuals. Did you have rock piles for the rock dwellers to claim as territory? You could either try more rocks, or putting the rocks at one end of the tank to incentivize them to stay in one area. Good luck.
 

JerryJ

CCA Members
Hi Charlutz, your experience is interesting if a bit confusing (because several others have reinforced my impression that this combination rarely works). How big was your tank? I do have a couple of rock piles, but the cichlids in question hadn't settled into defined territories...they pretty much swam everywhere in the tank, and chased the catfish whenever they saw them. I agree that this probably depends somewhat on individual fish personalities, but the J. transcriptus went after the catfish after only one day in the tank. Attacking the catfish gave the impression of being a hardwired instinct.
 

Charlutz

Members
I had the petricolas in all my tanks. I moved them around when the cichlids started breeding if I wanted to keep fry, and I usually did. The transcriptus were with them in a 15g, the brichardi and leleupi in 20’s, one a long and one a high. I also had them in my 75’s, 125g and 210g. I just don’t recall hostilities being much of an issue with them. The cichlids mostly ignored them or ushered them out of the cichlid territory.
 
Top