Tony
Alligator Snapping Turtle/Past Pres
Interesting thread. Sorry about your GT, Andrew... though it sounds like you have the wild ones coming up.
I generally don't mix old world and new world (or lakes/regions for that matter), but don't look down on folks who do. I have one tank where I'm using Malawi mbuna as target fish for a group of juvenile P. bifaciatus. Both like hard-ish water and NLS pellets, so whatever. If I took the mbuna out, the 2.5" bifaciatus would certainly kill each other (with only 4 in a 75).
From what I've read and started to notice with my own fish, I think that the biggest detraction between mixing new and old world fish (besides chemistry and diet for very specialized rift lake fish like Tropheus) is body language. There are subtle cues that Central American cichlids have learned that fish from other areas just don't get... beyond the obvious flaring and mouthing. Changing of colors or patterns in the body or wiggling a certain way is something that some fish just won't pick up on. And then there's pheromones....
Anyway, not saying it's bad to do, just explaining an often-overlooked difference/incompatibility between fish from different parts of the world.
I generally don't mix old world and new world (or lakes/regions for that matter), but don't look down on folks who do. I have one tank where I'm using Malawi mbuna as target fish for a group of juvenile P. bifaciatus. Both like hard-ish water and NLS pellets, so whatever. If I took the mbuna out, the 2.5" bifaciatus would certainly kill each other (with only 4 in a 75).
From what I've read and started to notice with my own fish, I think that the biggest detraction between mixing new and old world fish (besides chemistry and diet for very specialized rift lake fish like Tropheus) is body language. There are subtle cues that Central American cichlids have learned that fish from other areas just don't get... beyond the obvious flaring and mouthing. Changing of colors or patterns in the body or wiggling a certain way is something that some fish just won't pick up on. And then there's pheromones....
Anyway, not saying it's bad to do, just explaining an often-overlooked difference/incompatibility between fish from different parts of the world.