Thanks. They have plenty of larger rocks to choose from but she always finds somewhere weird to lay them, I'm amazed that the male can even fertilize them sometimes as large as he is. The eggs did very well and she's now guarding the largest batch of Haitians I have ever seen anywhere well over 1,000. Tank has two larger fry hiding in the rocks I'm hoping they can eat all these fry up because I definitely don't want to raise anymore. I really should vacuum them out now but the parents go crazy after I do that. The young pair I sold is going to a very good fish keeper so I'm happy about that.